The controversy over the theology of arius was really over how to imagine a connection between a wholly transcendent god and the present world. Arius, the presbyter of alexandriaarius, a presbyter, tried to solve. The reasoning behind this statement is that jesus was born and died and therefore could not be god. Alexandria and then been ordained by a bishop favorable to arius. He argued that arius view, that christ had come into existence at a finite point in time, violated christs eternality and aseity i. This is a challenge for the church as it tries to fulfil the mission he has received from christ, the messiah, the lord, the son of god, and so on.
One hundred bishops attended, and eighty of them voted to excommunicate arius and his supporters. Alexandrian school of christology founded by clement of alexandria but origen is the famous student and theologian. The bishops at nicaea asserted that this son of god is of one substance with god his father. He was a more adamant champion of it, and a far more eloquent and persuasive speaker. His bishop, alexander, became alarmed when he noticed other clergy members picking up on arius s views, and in 319, he called a council. Dec 23, 2015 the story of the eastern church essentially hinges upon two centers of theological belief. Arius saw in jesus a mediator, divinely generated to connect the world with god.
Durham etheses the christology of nestorius and the. He was called a doctor of the church and is considered one of the greatest theologians in the christian faith. Athanasius 605 say that the son is one, and the word of god another. Also, during this period the antiochene school suffered from the popular teaching of paul of samosata who represented a new movement called dynamic monarcianism. Early christian history st athanasius of alexandria. The eastern bishops reacted with shock and indignation at being called arians. Essays on early christian christology, supplements to novum testamentum boston leiden.
Constantius came to power in alexandria and he again ordered deposition of athanasius. Alexandrian christology, however, originating in alexandria, a center of greek learning, emphasised the deity of jesus to the point of blurring the distinction between deity and humanity. Beginning with the arian debate at nicaea in 325 ad and continuing even beyond the council of chalcedon in 451 ad, the differences in theology between these two sees led to a great many controversies. Alexandrian theologians preoccupied with jesus divinity and developed a wordflesh christology 3 arian christological controversy in 4th century a. Lecturer in the department of theology at the faculty of philosophy and. And indeed it is not at all surprising that the words of arius, in his epistle to alexander of alexandria see athan. Athanasius of alexandria biography facts, childhood, life. Arianism is a christological doc trine first attributed to arius c. He was tall, handsome, earnestly religious, and eloquent in his arguments. It is considered whether the christology of nestorius falls within the permitted limits of chalcedon. The christian community of alexandria became sharply divided over the samosatene doctrine. He wrote also, the word of god came own person, because it was he alone, the image of the father, who could recreate man made after the image 10. The initial focus of arianism in alexandria was arius parish church of baucalis. Arius was was a libyan presbyter and ascetic, and priest in baucalis in alexandria, egypt.
The heresy of arius, the presbyter from alexandria, was to deny full. So, what was the soteriological problem with his image of christ. The lord created me at the beginning of his ways augustine his views on the book of. Narrative christological formulas summaries of jesus death and. For almost two decades after arius had supposedly died, decades in which christian intellectuals in rome, alexandria and the newly dedicated city of constantinople were intensely debating the merits of ideas arius had espoused, and during which his enemies would have used any story to add to arius infamy, even the bare fact of his death. His opponents continued their efforts to once again send him into exile. His christological teaching helped to form our understanding of the trinity we hold today. Pdf fifth century christology between soteriological perspective. His teachings about the nature of the godhead in christianity, which emphasized god the fathers uniqueness and christs subordination under the father, and his opposition to what would become the dominant. Arius of alexandria a presbyter from alexandria, arius, dusted off the samosatene doctrine, and presented it to the church once more. The arian controversy the arian controversy, sparked off by arius, a popular presbyter in the church of alexandria died 335 ad, centered. May 22, 2019 the christian church, like the judaic church before it, was committed to monotheism. But it was this very fact of the logical consistency of the theory which opened the eyes of the church.
Surely the opponents of arius and eusebius of nicomedia told them what men like justin martyr. Alexandrian scholastic way of authenticating theology, not through ecclesial. Arius, the presbyter of alexandriaarius, a presbyter, tried to solve this very mystery about the nature of christ. It is merely the christology of the third century theoretically carried to its logical conclusion. Arianism, in christianity, the christological position that jesus, as the son of god, was created by god. Idem, athanasius of alexandria and the foundation of traditional christology, in. Malchion, a converted sophist of the second half of the third century a. Arius could not stomach the coequal and coeternal trinity that had fully enveloped his christian community at alexandria. Texts used by arius a suggest son is a creature, the greatest. Arianism had its beginning with the theological investigations of arius of alexandria. Alexandria with its many different theologians was a prime location for a new christian theology to take place. He was educated by lucian, presbyter in antioch, and held a prominent position as presbyter in the church of alexandria when the arian controversy with bishop alexander began about 318 concerning the eternal deity of christ and his equality with the father. The lingering disagreements about which christological model was to be considered normative burst into the open in the early 4th century in what became known as the arian controversy, possibly the mostintense and mostconsequential theological dispute in early christianity. Pdf on jan 1, 2011, kirk macgregor published reference article nicene creed find, read and cite all the research you.
Ad 256336, a christian presbyter in alexandria, egypt. Arianism is a christological doctrine first attributed to arius c. Arius 256336ad, a priest of a large church in alexandria, was 63 years old when he started preaching the doctrinal beliefs that would later become known as arianism. Arius s genius was to push the christological question back to the origin of the preincarnate logos. An introduction to cyril of alexandria union resources. The socalled first creed of antioch is an excerpt from the letter that the eastern. Chapter one the hoots op the christology op nestorius the heresy of arius, the presbyter from alexandria, was to deny full divinity to jesus christ. Arius views about the trinity were declared heretical at the council of nicea, and the orthodox views of the trinity were spelled out concretely in the nicene creed.
Homoousian christians, including athanasius of alexandria, used arius and arianism as epithets to describe those who disagreed with their doctrine of coequal trinitarianism, a homoousian christology representing god the father and jesus christ the son as of one essence consubstantial and coeternal. The heresy of father arius christology, video 33 youtube. Arius was a prolific religious figure of early christianity from libya. Feb 18, 2014 an unfortunate credit to lucians account was that two of his pupils would be among the foremost heretics in early church history arius and eusebius of nicomedia. The virgin mary, theotokos, and christ, true god and true. Arianism, in christianity, the christological position that jesus, as the son of god, was. Because of arius assertions, a group of bishops met in nicaea to discuss arius theology. At the turn of the fourth century arius was already known to hold strong views on theology and was a close associate of lucian and meletius an egyptian schismatic against peter i, however following reconciliation in ad 306 arius was ordained as a deacon by peter i patriarch of alexandria. Alexander of alexandria bishop from alexandria arius attacks him in c. Arius imparted teachings on a created, finite nature of christ as opposed to equal divinity with god the father. Introduced the cross as a symbol of christianity crucifixions were banned. Lies in the consistent unity or continuous selfidentity of the logos or heavenly son through the three stages of its career so to speak.
Arius 256336 ce, a fairly obscure scholar and presbyter at alexandria and originally from libya, is said to have argued that the incarnation of jesus christ threatened that monotheistic status of the christian church, because he was not of the same. Meeting in council in the summer of 341 for the dedi cation of a church in antioch, they answered julius letter. Oxford edition of athanasius tracts against arianism, p. The godman university of birmingham etheses repository. Ariuss christology as a contemporary alexandrian theologian with athanasius. Or if there is no such extant manuscript, how would he interpreted the word was god in john 1. Arian theology holds that the son of god is not coeternal with god the father and is distinct from the father therefore subordinate to him. Susan wessel, cyril of alexandria and the nestorian controversy. Instead, jesus is a man theodore called him the assumed man in whom the word dwells, a man who has a special connection to god the word.
Pdf athanasius and the arian controversy rachel riddell. Living in alexandria, arius was faced head on with origens school and his own alexandrian assembly where syncretism between christianity and platonism was running rampant. The controversy seems to have arisen in a dispute between arius and his bishop, alexander of alexandria, though after nicea it was the young athanasius, deacon to alexander, who carried the. It has been accepted for inclusion in school of theology and seminary graduate. He was invited to come back to the city of alexandria and preach. Arianism, athanasius, and the effect on trinitarian thought. Father arius was a smart priest with extensive arguments from scripture. But the originator of the distinctive antiochene emphasis was diodore, later bishop of tarsus d.
Libyan christian priest of alexandria, egypt and the. Arius believed that jesus was a creature, a created god. It is thus that the doctrine of arius, which, in its main features, lucian may have already taught, is to be understood. Abstract this dissertation sets the christology of athanasius of alexandria in the context of its sources, and evaluates its reception up to the council of chalcedon. Along with eusebius of nicomedia, arius studied under lucian of antioch, whose views foreshadowed arius s christology. Since arius was an excellent orator, for athanasius to have been given this task, shows that he must have been greatly respected by alexander and probably a number of other bishops present. The arian controversy the arian controversy, sparked off by arius, a popular presbyter in the church of alexandria. Deposition of arius, and circular letter oxford translation by rev. Arius was a priest in the church of alexandria when he started teaching his views about the son. Nov 08, 2015 arius subordination of jesus to god caused much controversy in alexandria, and bishop alexander issued a harsh rebuttal to arius dissenting opinions. It was proposed early in the 4th century by arius of alexandria and was popular throughout much of the eastern and western roman empires.
The controversy is widely misunderstood by people today, who frequently hear completely erroneous things about it for example, that arius thought that christ was human, not divine, or that he was not really the son of god. Arius was a cultured and ascetic presbyter 256336 ad, a popular preacher from libya. However, as in mainstream trinitarianism, arianism holds that jesus christ is the son of god, who was begotten by god the father. Arius argued that both beings are powerful and godlike but jesus is not as god and the father is. The christology of jehovahs witnesses, also, is a form of arianism. He gained prominence as an opponent of paul of samosata, whose heretical views were condemned at antioch in 268. It was proposed early in the 4th century by arius of alexandria and was. Logos christology became the dominant teaching and he won favor of church and became a saint before his martyrdom. Eusebius of caesarea wrote his ecclesiastical historyrife with quotesjust 2 years after arius exile from alexandria and 2 years before the council of nicea. A presbyter and ascetic, he was a priest in baucalis in alexandria, egypt.
It was denounced as a heresy by the council of nicaea in 325. Pdf the attitude of the proarian bishops towards the emperor in. The letter of eusebius of caesarea describing the council of nicaea 335 iv. Theology from the university of athens 19921996 and of classical philology of. Pdf this article offers a contrary view to the modern myth of hellenic alexandria vs. After two and half years of exile, when both emperor constantine and arius had died, athanasius returned to alexandria. Constantines empire was divided into his three sons. Unlike arius, theodore firmly believed that the word is equal to the father, but the similarity of his thought about salvation to arius led him to argue that jesus is not god the word. Initially, he and a council of bishops decided to ban arius and his followers from receiving communion as punishment for their lack of obedience lynch 164.
1149 186 1252 730 1571 619 1259 971 1051 274 1588 463 1113 743 1377 282 1591 1396 1012 57 829